Tollie - singles and picture sleeves

Look for pock-marked vinyl with inferior sound quality. On some fake boxed logo styles, the "E" in "TOLLIE" is squared instead of curved.
fake label with squared "E"
genuine label with rounded "E"

Any Tollie record pressed in colored vinyl is fake.

Some enterprising counterfeiter reproduced the Vee-Jay 587 sleeve to create a poor quality (and non-existent) Tollie 9001 sleeve.
fake Tollie 9001 sleeve
genuine Vee-Jay 587 sleeve

It's hard to believe anyone would think this sleeve genuine.

Another fantasy sleeve.

Any Tollie 9008 picture sleeve with a die cut thumb tab is fake.
fake sleeve
genuine sleeve